Chautauqua County, NY Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Stockton Hotel $$ 33 reviews Bars, Burgers, American (716) 595-3505 2 S Main StStockton, NY 14784 Nickel Plate Depot $$ 8 reviews Bars, New American (716) 792-4400 131 Central AveBrocton, NY 14716 St. Stephens Cafe $ 7 reviews Cafes (716) 230-4391 2 West Main StBrocton, NY 14716 Monika's Delites $ 1 reviews Delis (716) 244-0657 Lily Dale, NY 14752 The Sunflower Cafe $ 8 reviews Desserts, Juice Bars & Smoothies, Sandwiches (716) 595-2700 8 Melrose DrLily Dale, NY 14752 Cassadaga Country Club $ 4 reviews Chicken Wings, New American, Golf (716) 595-3003 55 Frisbee RdCassadaga, NY 14718 The Lily $ 2 reviews Burgers, Pizza, Breakfast & Brunch 8 Melrose DrFredonia, NY 14063 Pizza Guru's $ 1 reviews Barbeque, Chicken Wings, Pizza (716) 230-4004 16 E Main StBrocton, NY 14716 Crosby's $ 1 reviews Convenience Stores, Pizza, Gas Stations (716) 224-1060 6086 ELake RdMayville, NY 14757 American Legion J W Dill Post 434 $ 1 reviews American, Salad, Pizza (716) 792-4345 110 E Main StBrocton, NY 14716 Olde Corner Deli $ 25 reviews Delis (716) 753-7390 6344 Centralia HartfieldDewittville, NY 14728